Best Pacifiers Reviews and Ratings
One of the number one things that we strive to do as parents is to comfort our babies and keep them happy and content. This can be quite a challenge at times and it never hurts to have a little help. There are many tools and products out there that can help us along our parenting journey and one of those very popular items is a pacifier. There are endless options of pacifiers out there all with a wide variety of different prices and features.
Our Top 3 Picks
This can make it more difficult to choose a good pacifier for your baby, but fortunately for you, that’s where we come in. We took our time researching and evaluating the different pacifiers out there so that you wouldn’t have to. So, please enjoy our list of the very best pacifiers out there for your baby!
10 Best Pacifiers
1. Philips Avent SCF190/01
Distributed at Hospitals
The Soothie pacifier is not just popular with the general public, but it is also a very popular choice for hospitals as well. There are over 2000 hospitals across the United States that distribute these to patients and many even use them in NICUs. This is likely due to the high success rate of getting babies to take this specific pacifier. Knowing that these are pacifiers that are trusted by medical professionals makes them even more enticing and you can rest easy knowing that it is a very safe and effective pacifier choice.
One solid piece
Multiple color options
Distributed at hospitals
You'll likely be surprised to learn that this product from Phillips Avent is the least expensive pacifier on the entire list. It is super affordable and almost anyone can easily get one. With its impressively low price and all of its amazing features such as being one solid piece and hospital-grade silicone, this is a pacifier with unbelievably high value to it.
If you are looking for one of the best pacifiers on the market with one of the best prices too, this is the pacifier for you. It is an extremely popular option and for very good reason. It is easy to clean, comes as one solid piece of high-quality hospital-grade silicone, and is accepted by most babies unlike many other pacifiers out there. There is no doubt that this is a great pacifier that you definitely want to consider getting some of for your sweet baby.
- Most babies will willingly take this pacifier
- Hospital-grade silicone is strong and durable
- One-piece design is safer
- Easy to clean and sanitize
- Shaped perfectly for little mouths
- Well-trusted even by medical professionals
- High-quality material that is safe for your baby
- Bulky outer shield
2. The First Years GumDrop
This company goes out of there way to really ensure the safety of their products for your precious babies. This wonderful pacifier is free of dangerous chemicals and substances to help protect your baby. It is BPA-free, latex-free, and phthalate-free. You definitely don’t need to worry about this product being unsafe for your baby.
Tab for gripping
Pacifier clip hole
The GumDrop option from The First Years is another surprisingly inexpensive pacifier on our list. It is very affordable coming in very low on the list in regard to price. With its many great features and high quality, it’s definitely got a really wonderful overall value.
This is another pacifier that is widely accepted by most babies hinting at one of the reasons that it is widely used in hospitals as well. It’s got a great design and is made of high-quality silicone at an affordable price. This makes it a great choice for almost every family.
- One-piece construction makes cleaning and sanitizing easy
- Durable silicone can’t be easily damaged
- Bright colors are fun and attractive
- Hole on tab allows you to attach almost any pacifier clip
- Shaped to not cover your baby’s little nose
- Free of potentially dangerous things like BPA and phthalates
- Nipple doesn’t have as much give as other options
3. Wubbanub Giraffe
One really cool thing is that it is super easy to wash. You can choose to hand wash this stuffed animal/pacifier combo or you can simply wash it in your washing machine! That way you don’t have to worry about it getting dirty since it is so easy to clean it.
The Wubbanub is understandably the most expensive option on the list. This is because it is really more than just a pacifier. The awesome stuffed animal and additional comfort make this pacifier combo well-worth it’s cost and gives it incredible value even at its higher price point.
There really isn’t much room to go wrong with this amazing choice. It’s a great way to provide your baby with ample suckling comfort in addition to plenty of snuggly comfort as well. It’s adorable, harder to lose, and easy to care for. Your baby is nearly guaranteed to love this great pacifier. While it does have great value, it is definitely more expensive so the only consideration may be if you are on a tighter budget, you may want to choose a more inexpensive option.
- Free of dangerous substances such as BPA and phthalates
- Soft animal plush provides additional comfort for your baby
- Easier to find and harder to lose than other pacifiers
- Can be easily washed in the washing machine
- Made using one of the absolute best pacifiers ever made
- No cracks or crevices in pacifier for bacteria to become trapped in and grow
- Pacifier is not removable from the animal
4. NUK Newborn
This option is special because it is made to be orthodontic which means that it will not negatively impact your baby's teeth and jaw development. The shape of the nipple is perfect to fit comfortably up into your baby’s palette while also allowing optimal tongue movement. The nipple also has a very thin neck so that it doesn’t keep your baby’s jaw open too wide.
Made in the USA
This is a product that is fairly close to the bottom of the list in regard to its cost. It’s certainly very affordable with a great value due to not only it’s inexpensive price tag, but also it’s amazing features and high-quality design.
Being of one-piece construction and made of 100% silicone gives this pacifier some great benefits and advantages. The orthodontic nipple adds even more amazing benefits to it. It’s affordable and high-quality so it can certainly be a great choice for most babies. If you’re particularly concerned about jaw and teeth development and you don’t mind too much about colors, this is a perfect pacifier choice for your baby.
- Orthodontic nipple helps to ensure proper development
- One-piece construction is easy to clean and sanitize
- Nowhere for bacteria to get trapped
- Silicone is high-quality and durable
- Shield is shaped to prevent irritation
- Doesn’t get in the way of baby’s nose
- Colors are sent at random without being able to choose
5. MAM Night Glow in the Dark
Glow in the Dark
Probably the most special feature on these adorable and effective options is that they glow in the dark! The shield on these pacifiers is made to glow in the dark to make these pacifiers perfect for use at night. They have a comforting and soft glow to them that allows both you and your baby to easily and quickly find them in the dark. This helps to quickly soothe baby back to sleep instead of you having to turn the lights on to look for the pacifier and upsetting your baby even more.
Glow in the dark
SkinSoft silicone nipple
These glow in the dark pacifiers land around the middle of the list price-wise. With their many wonderful features such as being easy to find and having a super soft orthodontic nipple, these are some wonderful options with great overall value.
These are the perfect choice for bed time for your baby. They come at a very reasonable price and wonderful value with multiple great features. They are definitely worth the purchase, especially if you are looking for a pacifier that will help make night time wake ups much easier on you and your baby.
- Orthodontic nipple helps protect proper development
- Super soft silicone helps replicate the feeling of real skin
- Cute designs are playful and fun
- Included case can be used to carry or sanitize pacifiers
- Glow in the dark design makes finding the pacifier in the dark super easy
- Multiple holes in the shield help to allow air circulation and prevent irritation
- Multiple-piece construction may require more frequent replacement
6. FCTRY Mustachifier
The back of this funny pacifier features a very convenient little handle on it. The handle is clear to add to the cute and comical mustache effect. It moves up and down easily and provides the perfect spot to safely grip the pacifier without contaminating the nipple at all. It’s a great way to put it in and out of your baby’s mouth and it also provides the absolute perfect place to place a pacifier clip on your baby’s pacifier to make it harder to lose track of and less likely to get dirty.
This is a relatively expensive option snagging the number two spot on our list as far as price goes. It’s understandable that it would cost more since it obviously requires more materials than other options and therefore would have a higher cost of production. It’s very unique though and definitely has a good value to it with its special features.
This is a fun and funny pacifier that is sure to get some great laughs and make fun memories. There may be a chance that it won’t be as easily accepted by your baby as some of the other popular pacifier options out there but at absolute least, you’ll be able to get some great pictures and it makes a wonderful baby gift too.
- Handle provides a perfect place to securely and easily attach a pacifier clip
- Vent holes keep air circulating to prevent potential irritation to baby’s face
- Clear pacifier and shield help add to the overall affect of the pacifier
- Mustache provides something funny and cute for the baby
- BPA-free and completely safe for your baby
- Silicone nipple is soft and orthodontic
- Heavier than typical pacifiers
7. Ulubulu Expression Set
Cute and Funny Phrases
These are extra fun and cute because of their adorable little phrases. Each pacifier has a different short phrase on it. They range from funny things like “mute button” and “pull to sound alarm” to simple and cute things like “hi” and “rock star”. These little sayings add to the enjoyment of these stylish pacifiers.
These pacifiers are near the middle of the list as far as the price goes. These are pretty affordable and their awesome features, high-quality design, and entertaining phrases give this set great value!
Ulubulu pacifiers are fantastically well-designed. They have plenty of great features like ergonomic silicone nipples, vented shields, convenient handles, and fun phrases! They are stylish and with great value, these can certainly be a good choice for almost any baby. Just remember that they may need to be replaced more often since they are not of one-piece construction like some other options.
- Shield is designed ergonomically to provide optimal comfort
- Orthodontic nipple won’t cause any damage to your baby’s development
- Soft silicone nipple soothes baby very well
- Handle adds to overall convenience
- Cute phrases make them fun for adults too
- Holes in the shield allow air to circulate to prevent irritation to your baby
- Multiple-piece construction may require more frequent replacements
8. Nuby 2-Pack
Something that is unique and cool is that the neck of the pacifiers includes little nubs or bumps. These nubs fall where your baby’s gums will be on the pacifier. This is a great way to soothe and stimulate your baby’s gums which further adds to the calming properties of this pacifier.
Assorted fun colors
This set falls at the high-end of the middle of our list. Even being a little higher than some of the other pacifiers on the list, it is still quite affordable and has a fantastic value to it. This is thanks to its many awesome and unique features such as modern design, flex action nipple, and teething nubs.
This is not your run of the mill pacifier. It has a very stylish and unique look to it in addition to other innovative features. It mimics a natural nipple exceptionally well and does nothing to inhibit proper development. This is a really great pacifier for any baby, but especially for breastfed babies. As long as you aren’t too specific about choosing colors, this is a great pacifier that you should really consider.
- Shield has holes for air circulation and handle for convenience
- Orthodontic shape prevents damage to development
- Nipple flexes to imitate mother’s nipple
- One-piece construction is easy to keep clean and sanitize
- Design is modern and stylish
- High-quality that is durable and strong
- Colors are sent at random
The very special and unique thing is that they are designed for older kiddos. Most pacifiers out there are sized and shaped for little babies, but some babies hang on to their pacifier and the comfort they receive from suckling past the infant stage. These are especially for toddlers aged 1 ½ years to 3 years old. The larger nipple is perfect for their bigger mouths and allows your older child to easily and comfortably continue to receive comfort from soothing suckling.
Bright assorted colors
Falling in the middle of the list, these larger pacifiers are absolutely affordable for most families. Their multiple good features and uniquely large nipple size give them their good overall value.
These are some really great pacifiers from an excellent company. They won’t be for everyone since they don’t work for little babies, but they are a fantastic choice for those of us that have toddlers that still use pacifiers.
- Perfect size and shape for older children that still like to use their pacifier
- Colors are fun and bright
- Shield designed to prevent irritation with air vents and curved design
- Orthodontic nipple won’t cause any damage to oral development
- Handle is helpful and convenient
- Classic design is cute and familiar
- Latex is very soft
- Can’t be used for little babies
- Latex can be potentially harmful for some
Each one of these Keep-it-Kleen pacifiers features a different fun character or design on the front of it. There are several different characters to choose from and it is likely that you’ll find your favorite animal! From Percy Puppy and Ethan Penguin to Bobby Bear and Adam Airplane, there are lots of great choices to enjoy. Even if you don’t fall for one of the characters, there are some other great designs to choose from like pink circles, flowers, and even a soccer ball! There is definitely something for everyone.
This pacifier is pretty high up there in regard to cost. It may not be as affordable as many of the other choices but with its innovative and unique closing mechanism in addition to other great features, it certainly has really great value.
RaZbaby has created a really great product that can certainly be a good choice for most babies. It’s going to be especially great if you or your baby tends to drop the pacifier a good bit. However, if you’re on a tight budget, you may want to choose a more affordable option.
- Nipple mimics a natural nipple to effectively soothe baby
- Vented shield keeps air circulating
- Closing mechanism keeps the pacifier clean
- Protected nipple is safer and healthier
- Built-in case can’t be misplaced or lost
- Characters and designs are cute and fun
- Built-in case can leave marks on the baby’s face
Product Evaluation Criteria
Pacifiers are a product that we allow our most precious little babies to put into their mouths and suck and that includes even newborns. You really have to be able to put a lot of trust into a product to do something like that. We all want products for our children that we can rely on and know that they are safe and won’t cause our children harm. We very carefully evaluated the safety of these pacifiers to make sure that they were all completely suitable for use with our sweetest little ones.
Going back to the fact that pacifiers are an item designed to go into your baby’s mouth, you need to know that it is a high-quality product. You don’t want to put some cheaply made and potentially unsafe product into your little one’s mouth. We considered the materials of the pacifiers and how they were made so that we could be sure to give you a list full of very high-quality pacifiers to try with your baby.
It isn’t just about what a pacifier is made of that matters. How the pacifier is designed and made makes a huge difference too. Finding a pacifier with a good shape to the nipple and design to the shield is necessary. Other additional features like a place to attach a pacifier clip and one-piece construction are great bonuses in the design too. We chose a good variety of well-designed pacifiers with various features to give you plenty of options that are all made very well.
Pacifiers are generally low-priced items that are a fairly inconsequential purchase for most families. However, they do come in a range of prices and you always want to get the most bang for your buck. When choosing the pacifiers for our list, we made sure to include a fair variety of pacifiers of different prices. More importantly, we took the time to consider the value of the pacifiers. We made sure that every pacifier on the list had a high value for its price and would be well-worth the purchase.
The user reviews are a very important aspect of our evaluation process. They are one of the absolute best sources of legitimate and accurate information out there for the products we evaluate and recommend. User reviews are written by the real consumers of a product. That means that they are about the opinions and experiences of real people that have purchased and used the pacifiers. We reviewed many of these for each pacifier that we evaluated when choosing the pacifiers for our list so that we could know we were bringing you the best of the best.
Is it okay for breastfed babies to get a pacifier?
Yes! All babies can use a pacifier and if you use the pacifier properly, there is no reason to worry about it negatively impacting your breastfeeding relationship with your child. Just remember that the pacifier should never be replacing a feeding and your baby shouldn’t be suckling on the pacifier when they are actually hungry. If you struggle with milk supply, keep your use of the pacifier fairly minimal to increase the time baby spends at the breast, but don’t feel like you must cut the pacifier out completely.
When should I introduce a pacifier?
You can introduce a pacifier almost immediately after your baby is born. However, it is often recommended that breastfed babies don’t get a pacifier until after the mother’s milk supply is established and the baby is used to breastfeeding at around 4 to 6 weeks old. This will help to avoid nipple confusion or milk supply problems.
When should I wean my child of the pacifier?
There is no specific time or age that it becomes necessary to wean your child off of the pacifier. It is a personal decision that you, your partner, and your child will need to figure out together. There is a very wide range of ages in which it is normal to quit using a pacifier. Some babies only use pacifiers for the first few months of life while others use them well into their toddler years. You just have to base your decision off of your child and your personal preferences.
How do I clean one?
It is usually recommended to sterilize pacifiers before initial use by using one of several methods including boiling or microwaving in a sterilization container or bag. Some people are more comfortable continuing to clean their pacifiers this way but generally that isn’t really necessary. Most of the time you can wash your baby’s pacifier similarly to how you would a dish by cleaning it with warm, soapy water. Some pacifiers may be dishwasher safe, but always check the cleaning instructions from the manufacturer of the pacifier to be safe.
How often should I replace my baby’s pacifiers?
Recommendations on how often you need to replace a pacifier vary a good bit. It really depends on several factors including the use of the pacifier as well as the design of the pacifier. For example, pacifiers that are of one-piece construction require less frequent replacement because there isn’t anywhere for bacteria to get trapped and build up in them. If you are unsure about when your pacifier needs replaced, look at what the recommendation from the manufacturer is. Also, remember that if there is ever any sign of damage that the pacifier definitely needs to be replaced to avoid safety concerns.
My baby won’t takeit. Should I try another one?
Every baby is different and so is every pacifier. Most babies won’t take just any kind of pacifier. Most prefer one or two specific types of pacifier. It is hard to predict which pacifier may work best for your baby specifically. Unfortunately, it’s generally a process of trial and error to discover which pacifier is right for your little one. So, don’t lose hope if your baby doesn’t take the first pacifier that you try. It’s perfectly likely that they will like a different pacifier.